In a very early post on
the whole egalitarian/complementarian issue, I said that I didn’t like reading
pro-egalitarian arguments written by women because I tended to accuse them of “finding loopholes in what the Bible says because they
don’t like submitting.” It’s interesting reading back over where I was a year
ago, and comparing that to where I am now. One of the reasons I started this
blog was to document the journey, and I appreciate the record I have of the
ways different assumptions and confusions have been reshaped over time. An
important part of my conversion to egalitarianism has involved a new respect
for and love of the concept of submission; I now believe that it should be a way
of life – the way of life – for all Christians.
A couple of posts ago I spoke about magic, and I’m about to attempt some for
myself: Be amazefied, ladies and gentlemen, as I condense two giant ideas –
submission and love – into one not-too-lengthy* blog post!
Complementarian teaching on submission is aimed only
at women**, encouraging them to let men initiate, lead, protect and provide for
them. Submission seems to have become synonymous with Peter’s “gentle and quiet
spirit” which has morphed into just being “gentle and quiet,” causing most
passionate and loud-laughing women to question their submissiveness and therefore
their chances of impressing godly men. So submission is reduced to women
aiming to be less animated and men not thinking about it at all. (I have never once heard a man wishing he was
more submissive; hopefully by the end of this post, this fact will worry you as
much as it worries me.)
Egalitarian teaching on submission encourages both men
and women to follow Jesus’ example by humbly “taking the very nature of a
servant” and giving themselves up for others. I found it striking to read that
the word ‘Islam’ means ‘submission’; it made me wonder if we Christians had missed
the hugeness of submission by applying it to only one sex. Surely submission is
something that should define Christianity too, because it’s the way we live out
Jesus’ great command to love our neighbours as we love ourselves. As Darren Hanlon sings,
“love is just a lazy generalisation that we use for a hundred different feelings
and as many situations” – it’s a word we throw around a lot without ever
thinking through how to actually do it
(although we also know, thanks to DC Talk, that “Luv is a Verb“). I think 1 John
3:16 tells us how to do love: “This
is how we know what love is: Jesus Christ laid down his life for us. And we
ought to lay down our lives for our brothers and sisters.” Love is being like
Jesus: laying down our lives, humbling ourselves, looking to the interests of
others as well as ourselves, sacrificing for the sake of others; in short,
“submitting to one another out of reverence for Christ” (Ephesians 5:21).
I used to panic about what submission was supposed to
look like practically in marriage (of course, I thought it was my job alone, as
the wife; my husband was busy trying to work out what practical love looked
like), but I’m seeing it more often as I understand it better. As a treat, my
husband and I sometimes buy a box of ice creams. There are three flavours in
the box, and strawberry is our least favourite. Last time we bought them, I
knew there were two left and I headed to the freezer hoping that only one would
be strawberry so that I could eat it and leave my husband the one he preferred. My husband takes
our son for a couple of hours every morning so that I can sleep for longer. We
both aim for submission, which looks a little like a friendly dance (“You go
first!” “No, you go first!” etc.,
etc.). He lets me initiate, and I let him initiate. We support and encourage
each others’ gifts and passions. He leads where he’s strong and defers where
he’s weak, and I do likewise; we recognise and embrace the fact that God has
made us complementary in many ways.
In our best moments, our
marriage is like a tiny and mysterious version of the Church, a body in which
there is no division and each of its parts have equal concern for the other;
“if one part suffers, every part suffers with it; if one part is honoured, every
part rejoices with it” (1 Corinthians 12:25-26). And it’s not just husbands and
wives who make up the Church and are therefore called to adopt the attitude of
Christ Jesus and be servant-hearted, or “slaves of all,” as Jesus puts it in
Mark 10:44; in all relationships
Christians must “do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit, but in
humility consider others better than yourselves” (Philippians 2:3).
Outside of marriage,
submission may mean washing up your flatmate’s dishes without keeping tab of
how many nights now you’ve done it because she hasn’t. It may mean offering to
make your colleague a cup of tea every time you fix one for yourself. It may
mean tidying up the mess in the lounge room even though it was your brothers
who created it. It may mean sticking to your position at the back of the field
even though your team still hasn’t scored. It may mean biting your tongue, it
may mean looking for new chances to show kindness, it may mean losing
self-righteousness, time or money, and it may mean talking to someone on
their own at church even though you’ve noticed your buddy Jordan is back from
Europe and you haven’t had a chance to catch up with him yet. There are so many
chances each day for all of us to serve, to submit, to be humble and loving,
that it’s almost ridiculous to suggest that such a massive theme should apply
merely to a Christian wife as she is to relate to her husband, as is too often
the case.
In last Saturday’s paper,
Sandy Gordon, a sport psychologist, is quoted as saying this: “It’s important
to realise that the best teams in the world aren’t full of well-rounded people
who do everything well. They’re full of people with particular, complementary
skills, whose goals for the team trump their individual goals.” The thought of
every person in the world working alongside each other towards a goal of peace
and harmony is one that fills my heart with fuzziness and makes me long for
heaven. This is submission, this
surrender of our own goals and selfishness and desires and pride and resources
and ability for the sake of others! And this is love. Christ was servant-hearted, humble and loving, someone who
repeatedly and willingly gave himself up for others (including those who hated
him). His submission is what makes him so compelling, so worthy of worship and
adoration, so worthy of following.
It’s a beautiful guide and goal for all of his disciples, as we strive to love
a little more like him and taste a piece of heaven here on earth.
///
* Okay, it was a little lengthy.
** For an example, click
on this link, search for the words “And I think” and then read the paragraph
that follows. I originally saw this sermon on the Council for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood website months ago, but they’re currently updating their site so I found it elsewhere.